Earlier I found it too difficult to handle threaded comments on my blog. But now it seems, we have lot more options than only 2 plugins earlier. And the new plugins are extremely simple requiring no template edits. Brian also updated his plugin for WordPress 2.5 and fixed some bugs but still is very difficult to implement for a newbie blogger. So let’s look at almost all threading comments plugins we have now to choose from:
2. YATCP – A nice and simple plugin implementing trackback separation also. Easier to implement but still requires lot of tweaking.
Now its time to welcome some new plugins(atleast new for me if they existed before)
3. Ajax Comment Reply – One of very powerful plugins enabling ajax replying, threaded support, email to administrator of replies, pagination of comments and ajax editing of comments for administrator in post page. Requires little or no template edit for threaded comments. Also support gravatar. Plugin page is in chinese so for english version check here.
4. WordPress Thread Comments – Very powerful comment plugin just made for threaded comments feature but support ajax reply too. (Check compatibility with other Ajax Comment and non ajax comment plugins.) Again requires little or no template edit. Plugin page is in chinese – for english version check here.
5. Ajaxed WordPress – Very Powerful and Huge Plugin mainly for converting your WordPress Blog into ajaxified blog adding ajax to nearly everything. But includes threaded comment support also via inline comments and inline comment form module. Little or No Template Edit required for this one too.
So you see, now we have 5 options to make our comments threaded. So you have no excuse to not have them on your blog. Afterall they make lives of commentors easy.
BTW NSPeaks uses Ajax Comment Reply(Number 3 above) here for threaded comments.